This is awesome! I defended SUPERMAN RETURNS on many occasions. The ending was a little long, yes, but the movie filled my expectations in every fanboy way.

Superman Returns was incredible, the best superhero movie of all time. Very much underrated! I just watched it 3 times in a row it's so good. I don't think Singer has to go “wrath of khan” on the sequel because if he does another one just like 'Returns' it will be fine with me. Returns was a masterpiece.

The idea that there is going to be a reboot, is terrible.

I'm with you Bheki. I would love to see Singer continue with SUPERMAN but it looks like he is returning to X-MEN (which is exciting in itself) I guess it is always possible that he could return to it in the future, but based on how the film did financially, I'd say we're more likely to see a reboot. My one wish is they get someone good to direct that will put the emotional weight of the story first over just making an over-the-top action film AKA crapfest

And hopefully we will get to see Tarantino's dissertation even sooner than this. As all things are with him, I imagine that it is just brilliant.

I'm with you Bheki. I would love to see Singer continue with SUPERMAN but it looks like he is returning to X-MEN (which is exciting in itself) I guess it is always possible that he could return to it in the future, but based on how the film did financially, I'd say we're more likely to see a reboot. My one wish is they get someone good to direct that will put the emotional weight of the story first over just making an over-the-top action film AKA crapfest

And hopefully we will get to see Tarantino's dissertation even sooner than this. As all things are with him, I imagine that it is just brilliant.

Any word on whether or not Tarantino has finished his review? Where can we read it?

I also thought SR was great; very underrated. Since Singer has chosen not to publicly explain/defend his choices, I'd like to get a real professional's take on what the film was really all about.

Not sure I'd like to see a Singer sequel though. SR is a wonderful “stand alone” effort. It's Donner's 1978 film; seen through a prism. This Superman is not merely a celebration of “Americana” but a natural outgrowth of human culture.

Superman Returns was “alright” at best. The plot had serious issues and logic fallacies left, right and center. If you’re familiar with the terms fridge logic and fridge horror, here are some lessons and questions I came away with that might strike you as horrifying or just odd.

-At the end of Superman II, Superman gives Lois an amnesia inducing kiss that makes her forget the tryst she had with him. Why isn’t she freaked out about possibly being raped by Superman without her knowledge when she finds out her sick kid is really his and not her fiance’s?

-Superman is the creepiest and scariest stalker ever. Also, he’s a deadbeat dad.

-Lois Lane is a whore. If she had only a couple weeks before finding out she was “late”, then that means she hooked up with her fiance immediately after Superman left for Krypton.

-Other than being a little jealous of Superman, James Marsden’s character is more morally sound and just a better all around person than the hero and really makes you feel sorry for him by the time the credits roll because you know he’s getting royally screwed.

-Superman lands on the kryptonite continent and immediately becomes weak enough to be stabbed, but is somehow able to lift the same continent shortly thereafter and toss it into space… How exactly does that make sense?

I remember there being other things, but I haven’t watched it since I saw it in theatres back when it came out in 2006, so I just went with the really huge glaring ones.