A Whale of a Time: Saying goodbye to GordonandtheWhale.com

Chase Whale

by: Chase Whale
August 31st, 2011

Well, this is the hardest article I’ll ever have to write, but it has to be done. Next month, Gordon and the Whale will be closing its digital doors as a daily website. You will be able to access our archived articles, but come August 31st, there will no longer be fresh content.

I know this may come as a shock, so let’s take a look back and celebrate how far GATW has come and discuss the future. I’m going to give you the abridged version because, well, hopefully most of you reading this have been following us for a long time.

Back in 2007, Rusty Gordon and I had an idea to start a website that would be based solely on us filming ourselves arguing over whatever movie we just saw. If you’ve ever been around Rusty and I together, you know our humor towards each other is both loving and morbid. I pitched this idea to my cousin, who went to school for web design, and he told me he’d build us a site if we were truly serious about the idea. All we needed was a name. Thus, GordonandtheWhale.com was born - a website that sounded like a children’s book but read like two guys who hated each other. It was all out of love, really.

Once the site got rolling, we’d see every film that opened on that Friday and would have our video or written reviews up by Sunday. It was expensive, but we did it because we loved it.

Then everything changed. We were discovered by a well-respected publicist in Dallas, TX. She enjoyed our wit, humor, and style and brought us on as press, meaning we'd get to see movies for free and before they opened. This allowed us to actually get our reviews up in a timely fashion. To add icing to that cake, we also started getting invited to do interviews with actors and directors coming to town - GATW’s very first was William Fichtner.

A few months later, studios started adding us to their press lists, and we eventually began sponsoring advance screenings, giving away passes. More interview opportunities with bigger talent started coming our way. It was pretty kick-ass and I thought that was what “making it” as a movie website was all about.


THE VERY FIRST RESERVED SEATING SIGN FOR GATW

Around Christmas of 2008, we brought on James Wallace; he was a bright and persistent young man and, to this day, I’ve never met anyone more passionate about film than him. When we brought on James, well, that’s when things started to really happen for us. Because of him, GATW eventually became studios' largest sponsor for the Dallas-Fort Worth area - James gave us a visual presence behind all that wit and humor. He is the guy who loves being in front of a large crowd and can handle both hecklers and eager movie geeks.

We eventually attended our first film festival together - SXSW - and that’s when we discovered a whole other world of movie blogging.


GATW'S FIRST FESTIVAL TOGETHER

In April 2009, we brought on Kate Erbland (you can read Kate's very first review HERE), who forever changed the way GATW would write. Since that April, Kate has copy edited almost every piece of work posted on GATW, making sure our grammar was correct and that we didn’t sound like complete idiots (half-idiots is okay by Internet standards). You see, Kate’s really smart and has a degree in English - I dropped out of college to chase this whole movie blogging dream and didn’t pay too much attention in school about grammar and punctuation, which was now a crucial part of my life.

Kate began writing reviews for us and eventually became our head film critic. Anyone who has steadily followed Kate's film criticism career will agree that she can hold her own against any other online film critic working today. It was through her writing that I learned how to capture the feeling of fun in film criticism, whether it be positive or negative. Go ahead and take this time to read one of her reviews and you’ll see exactly what I’m talking about - you'll have as much fun reading it as she did writing. I suggest either STAR TREK or CLASH OF THE TITANS.

In 2010, I applied and got accepted into the Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association, I then later moved to Austin's Austin Film Critics Association. By asking for advice and criticism on my work, I became a real writer. At the 2010 Austin Film Festival, I was on a film criticism panel with Dallas Morning News' Chris Vognar, Film School Rejects' Neil Miller, The New Yorker's David Denby, and the Los Angeles Times' Kenneth Turan. I was beyond honored to be a part of this - it was one of the greatest moments of my life.

It wasn’t until James attended CineVegas (RIP) that the Internet started to pay attention to us. It was there that we got our first official EXCLUSIVE which major sites picked up. Soon after that, other news stories and original content began to show up on other websites.

In September 2009, James, Rusty, and I attended Fantastic Fest. We stayed in a tiny one bedroom hotel room with four other guys, and we had the best time of our lives. Life was pretty easy then. We'd use vacation time for festivals, see movies months before they were released, and dream about the day we could do this full-time.

And then another huge turning point happened in GATW’s career - we got accepted into the Sundance Film Festival. As nerdy as it was, I couldn’t decide which I was more excited about: getting accepted or being asked by Film School Rejects' Neil Miller, Slash Film's Peter Sciretta, and First Showing's Alex Billington to room with them during the festival. Kate had covered the LA Film Festival before, but tail-ended Sundance with us. It was no longer just three misfit boys going together to festivals, but one damn talented girl was now fully a part of the bunch.

Kate eventually became a very integral part of GATW, helping James and I make huge decisions on how we would structure our site. We started getting people from all over the world wanting to write for us and finally had a large staff. Life got pretty awesome - through GATW I was able to cover the Toronto International Film Festival and Cannes (with News Editor Joshua Brunsting). GATW even had a sponsor who paid for Josh and my trip to cover Cannes. Holy shit. Where do you go after that?

One thing I haven’t mentioned yet about our site - mainly because it’s not my primary focus of this article - is our financial success, how we ran as a business and paid for festivals. You see, a large number of people see the cool things we get to do and immediately assume there’s a lot of money involved. Let me be the first to tell you - there’s not. With the exception of two festivals, we paid everything out of pocket. Hotels, plane tickets, and food money all came out of our personal bank accounts. At first it was okay - we had faith that one day GATW would be able to pay for it - but it eventually took a toll on everyone.

We did sign with a large ad revenue company, Gorilla Nation, but that financial success never came. We did make a little bit of money off the site, but not enough to pay the writers, or even the editors. Our money went to our server and that was that. After four years of doing some of the biggest and best things with GATW, James, Kate, and I decided it’s best to leave at its peak and pursue other career opportunities. Kind of like what Jerry Seinfeld did with Seinfeld - quit while we're on top.

Trust me, this isn’t easy for anyone here. Letting go of this site is the hardest thing any of us could do, but if there’s a good time to let go, it’s right now.

Thank you all of the people who were consistent in their support of us throughout all of our trials and tribulations, the ones who believed in us, and the ones who helped carry us to the places we end up post-GATW life. I could name everyone individually, but the Academy would turn up the music and I wouldn’t be able to finish. The ones who I am speaking of, you know exactly who you are - I love you with all of my heart and you will forever be a large impact on my life. Thank you.

I will continue working in the film industry; look for that announcement soon. If you've been paying any attention to James Wallace on Twitter, you'll notice he's started his own site, IHeartCinema.net, which will fill the void of advance screenings and other sponsored film events that GATW hosted. As for Kate Erbland, well, I'm told she has a pretty groovy announcement coming soon. Check out the comments to see the rest of GATW's staff members discussing where you can find their work.

This last paragraph is dedicated to my mother, who, since day one, believed I could take my idea of writing about movies online and turn it into something great, and everyone who was ever a part of GATW. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for shedding tears with me and fighting so diligently until the very end. You are the reason I got a taste of hope. Go forth and conquer, my friends.

GATW’s fearless leader and your friendly neighborhood movie geek,

Chase Whale

Below are some of my favorite photos captured in GATW's career, quotes pulled from one of our reviews, and wonderful articles written about us. I am super-proud of everyone who helped me make this site possible.

Commenting Rules: Comments are intended to open up the discussion to our readers about the topics at hand, and as such should be offered with a positive and constructive attitude. If your comment is not relative to the above post or is disrespectful to the authors and readers, we reserve the right to delete it. Continued abuse of our good nature will result in banishment of the offender. Additionally, if you have any burning issues to point out to the GATW crew - typos, corrections, suggestions, or straight-up criticism - please email us instead of commenting here.

  • A Copeland86

    :( . good luck with all your future endevours GATW crew!

  • http://twitter.com/Jertown Jertown

    Loved reading this!  It’s sad that this chapter is over, but it’s really cool to see people pursue their dreams.  I wish all the GATW staff the best!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Annabelle-Mason/1474125706 Annabelle Mason

    You will certainly be missed! BOO HOO! Wish you much success in your upcoming endeavors!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Annabelle-Mason/1474125706 Annabelle Mason

    You will certainly be missed! BOO HOO! Wish you much success in your upcoming endeavors!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Annabelle-Mason/1474125706 Annabelle Mason

    You will certainly be missed! BOO HOO! Wish you much success in your upcoming endeavors!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Annabelle-Mason/1474125706 Annabelle Mason

    You will certainly be missed! BOO HOO! Wish you much success in your upcoming endeavors!

  • Stephen Cook

    Aw man… it was fun. You guys have been, and always will be, the best!
    Live long and propser

  • http://kclose3.com/blog kacey3

    Aww, I was supposed to be in that photo with Broken Lizard. It’s been a great ride working with you all, and I’ve learned so much from my time here. I’m going to miss it and I will never forget my time with Gordon and the whale.

  • http://kclose3.com/blog kacey3

    Aww, I was supposed to be in that photo with Broken Lizard. It’s been a great ride working with you all, and I’ve learned so much from my time here. I’m going to miss it and I will never forget my time with Gordon and the whale.

    • http://kclose3.com/blog kacey3

      I never really wrote for the site (one review, baby!), but I do fancy myself a writer, still. You can keep up with me Post-GATW at http://kclose3.com/blog. At the very least, a lot of the back end custom WordPress stuff is the same.

    • http://kclose3.com/blog kacey3

      I never really wrote for the site (one review, baby!), but I do fancy myself a writer, still. You can keep up with me Post-GATW at http://kclose3.com/blog. At the very least, a lot of the back end custom WordPress stuff is the same.

    • http://kclose3.com/blog kacey3

      I never really wrote for the site (one review, baby!), but I do fancy myself a writer, still. You can keep up with me Post-GATW at http://kclose3.com/blog. At the very least, a lot of the back end custom WordPress stuff is the same.

  • https://gordonandthewhale.com JamesWallace

    The only regret I have about my time with Gordon and the Whale is buying and wearing that hat in the photo above.

  • https://gordonandthewhale.com JamesWallace

    The only regret I have about my time with Gordon and the Whale is buying and wearing that hat in the photo above.

  • https://gordonandthewhale.com JamesWallace

    The only regret I have about my time with Gordon and the Whale is buying and wearing that hat in the photo above.

  • http://twitter.com/daniel_ohh Daniel Ogilvie

    Y’all were my favorite movie review site.  I’ll miss ya!

  • http://demiadejuyigbe.com demi adejuyigbe

    Aw, I came to you guys daily for movie news. I’m going to miss you guys, but I’m glad I got the chance to meet some of the lovely staff. Good luck on whatever your next thing may be!

  • http://demiadejuyigbe.com demi adejuyigbe

    Aw, I came to you guys daily for movie news. I’m going to miss you guys, but I’m glad I got the chance to meet some of the lovely staff. Good luck on whatever your next thing may be!

  • http://demiadejuyigbe.com demi adejuyigbe

    Aw, I came to you guys daily for movie news. I’m going to miss you guys, but I’m glad I got the chance to meet some of the lovely staff. Good luck on whatever your next thing may be!

  • http://demiadejuyigbe.com demi adejuyigbe

    Aw, I came to you guys daily for movie news. I’m going to miss you guys, but I’m glad I got the chance to meet some of the lovely staff. Good luck on whatever your next thing may be!

  • http://demiadejuyigbe.com demi adejuyigbe

    Aw, I came to you guys daily for movie news. I’m going to miss you guys, but I’m glad I got the chance to meet some of the lovely staff. Good luck on whatever your next thing may be!

  • http://demiadejuyigbe.com demi adejuyigbe

    Aw, I came to you guys daily for movie news. I’m going to miss you guys, but I’m glad I got the chance to meet some of the lovely staff. Good luck on whatever your next thing may be!

  • Doug Boehner

    All the kids are moving out of the house! Sad, but proud of you guys!

  • Anonymous

    NOOOOO!!!!  I will truly misss this site as it has become part of my daily reading routine!!!   Good luck with all your future endeavors!  You all rock!   Heroes are remembered, but legends never die!

  • http://twitter.com/DROCK1217 John Dotson

    Damn, I just discovered you guys too!! I’m gonna miss this site. :(

  • https://gordonandthewhale.com KateErbland

    It is tremendously hard to explain what GATW is, was, and will always be to me. In short terms, I’d say it’s my baby. But it’s more complicated than that – it never really was my baby. It was Chase and Rusty’s baby, and I was some sort of curious hybrid of step-mom and foster parent and nanny. I loved it as my own. The staff we assembled has consistently blown my mind in terms of their dedication, spirit, humor, talent, and skill. They inspired me every single day.
     
    I couldn’t even begin to name all of the other people outside of the GATW family that have also inspired and enriched me. I mean, I could, but I’d probably start to cry, and that’s just unseemly. And, considering I’m not even remotely leaving the film blog-o-sphere, just plain silly. You know who you are. I’ll see some of you guys tonight. I’ll see the rest of you at Sundance or SXSW. I’ll hug you a bit harder than usual, though.
     
    GATW has also opened many, many doors for me. As I announced a few weeks back, I am now on staff at MSN Movies’ The Hitlist blog, so you can catch my writing over there. And, beyond that, well…I’ve got a couple more announcements that I’ll be free to share later this week or so.
     
    You can keep up with all my exploits over at katerbland.com, and don’t be afraid to friend me on Facebook or to request to follow me on Twitter (I promise I’ll accept you).
     
    I could write something long-winded and cheesy here by way of conclusion (I mean, more long-winded and cheesier than everything else I’ve already put down here), but I’ll close by keeping it simple, to the point, and wrenchingly honest:
     
    Gordon and the Whale is the best thing that’s ever happened to me.

  • https://gordonandthewhale.com KateErbland

    It is tremendously hard to explain what GATW is, was, and will always be to me. In short terms, I’d say it’s my baby. But it’s more complicated than that – it never really was my baby. It was Chase and Rusty’s baby, and I was some sort of curious hybrid of step-mom and foster parent and nanny. I loved it as my own. The staff we assembled has consistently blown my mind in terms of their dedication, spirit, humor, talent, and skill. They inspired me every single day.
     
    I couldn’t even begin to name all of the other people outside of the GATW family that have also inspired and enriched me. I mean, I could, but I’d probably start to cry, and that’s just unseemly. And, considering I’m not even remotely leaving the film blog-o-sphere, just plain silly. You know who you are. I’ll see some of you guys tonight. I’ll see the rest of you at Sundance or SXSW. I’ll hug you a bit harder than usual, though.
     
    GATW has also opened many, many doors for me. As I announced a few weeks back, I am now on staff at MSN Movies’ The Hitlist blog, so you can catch my writing over there. And, beyond that, well…I’ve got a couple more announcements that I’ll be free to share later this week or so.
     
    You can keep up with all my exploits over at katerbland.com, and don’t be afraid to friend me on Facebook or to request to follow me on Twitter (I promise I’ll accept you).
     
    I could write something long-winded and cheesy here by way of conclusion (I mean, more long-winded and cheesier than everything else I’ve already put down here), but I’ll close by keeping it simple, to the point, and wrenchingly honest:
     
    Gordon and the Whale is the best thing that’s ever happened to me.

  • https://gordonandthewhale.com KateErbland

    It is tremendously hard to explain what GATW is, was, and will always be to me. In short terms, I’d say it’s my baby. But it’s more complicated than that – it never really was my baby. It was Chase and Rusty’s baby, and I was some sort of curious hybrid of step-mom and foster parent and nanny. I loved it as my own. The staff we assembled has consistently blown my mind in terms of their dedication, spirit, humor, talent, and skill. They inspired me every single day.
     
    I couldn’t even begin to name all of the other people outside of the GATW family that have also inspired and enriched me. I mean, I could, but I’d probably start to cry, and that’s just unseemly. And, considering I’m not even remotely leaving the film blog-o-sphere, just plain silly. You know who you are. I’ll see some of you guys tonight. I’ll see the rest of you at Sundance or SXSW. I’ll hug you a bit harder than usual, though.
     
    GATW has also opened many, many doors for me. As I announced a few weeks back, I am now on staff at MSN Movies’ The Hitlist blog, so you can catch my writing over there. And, beyond that, well…I’ve got a couple more announcements that I’ll be free to share later this week or so.
     
    You can keep up with all my exploits over at katerbland.com, and don’t be afraid to friend me on Facebook or to request to follow me on Twitter (I promise I’ll accept you).
     
    I could write something long-winded and cheesy here by way of conclusion (I mean, more long-winded and cheesier than everything else I’ve already put down here), but I’ll close by keeping it simple, to the point, and wrenchingly honest:
     
    Gordon and the Whale is the best thing that’s ever happened to me.

  • https://gordonandthewhale.com KateErbland

    It is tremendously hard to explain what GATW is, was, and will always be to me. In short terms, I’d say it’s my baby. But it’s more complicated than that – it never really was my baby. It was Chase and Rusty’s baby, and I was some sort of curious hybrid of step-mom and foster parent and nanny. I loved it as my own. The staff we assembled has consistently blown my mind in terms of their dedication, spirit, humor, talent, and skill. They inspired me every single day.
     
    I couldn’t even begin to name all of the other people outside of the GATW family that have also inspired and enriched me. I mean, I could, but I’d probably start to cry, and that’s just unseemly. And, considering I’m not even remotely leaving the film blog-o-sphere, just plain silly. You know who you are. I’ll see some of you guys tonight. I’ll see the rest of you at Sundance or SXSW. I’ll hug you a bit harder than usual, though.
     
    GATW has also opened many, many doors for me. As I announced a few weeks back, I am now on staff at MSN Movies’ The Hitlist blog, so you can catch my writing over there. And, beyond that, well…I’ve got a couple more announcements that I’ll be free to share later this week or so.
     
    You can keep up with all my exploits over at katerbland.com, and don’t be afraid to friend me on Facebook or to request to follow me on Twitter (I promise I’ll accept you).
     
    I could write something long-winded and cheesy here by way of conclusion (I mean, more long-winded and cheesier than everything else I’ve already put down here), but I’ll close by keeping it simple, to the point, and wrenchingly honest:
     
    Gordon and the Whale is the best thing that’s ever happened to me.

  • Pingback: An Inadvertently Not-For-Profit Film Site Says Goodbye « Movie City News

  • http://www.gmanreviews.com Andrew Robinson

    I will definitely miss all of y’all… and this site was so special to me… while it does fall under the category of “film blog” I always saw it as special and different from the rest. 

    *tear*

  • http://twitter.com/toscreenshots James McNally

    Best of luck to you, Chase (whom I’ve met) and to the rest of the gang (whom I haven’t). Will you still get to come to Toronto for TIFF this September? Would love to hear about your new career! :)

  • http://twitter.com/toscreenshots James McNally

    Best of luck to you, Chase (whom I’ve met) and to the rest of the gang (whom I haven’t). Will you still get to come to Toronto for TIFF this September? Would love to hear about your new career! :)

  • Susan Garfield

    Thank you for all that you and your talented staff has done.
    I wish all of you much success in your new venture(s).

  • Susan Garfield

    Thank you for all that you and your talented staff has done.
    I wish all of you much success in your new venture(s).

  • Susan Garfield

    Thank you for all that you and your talented staff has done.
    I wish all of you much success in your new venture(s).

  • Susan Garfield

    Thank you for all that you and your talented staff has done.
    I wish all of you much success in your new venture(s).

  • http://twitter.com/flynnofilm Flynn O’Connor

    This is why http://reelnewz.com is sadly, part-time and covering certain local (Austin, TX) events until real ad sponsorships happen. Movie News websites just don’t pay enough to support real news and video gathering! Sorry we won’t be seeing you on the line anymore Whales…but this is the biz. The line to fame only shortens through attrition.

  • http://twitter.com/flynnofilm Flynn O’Connor

    This is why http://reelnewz.com is sadly, part-time and covering certain local (Austin, TX) events until real ad sponsorships happen. Movie News websites just don’t pay enough to support real news and video gathering! Sorry we won’t be seeing you on the line anymore Whales…but this is the biz. The line to fame only shortens through attrition.

  • http://twitter.com/EricDSnider EricDSnider

    Chase will do ANYTHING to avoid sharing a room with me at Sundance.

  • http://www.fusedfilm.com Michael Lee

    I was just starting to read your blog too, and put it  on my rss feed.  So sad to see you go.  I remember hearing about you guys when I attended the JJ Abrams and Edgar Wright panel at the LAFF in 2010.  Good luck to everyone in the staff and their future endeavors

  • A Perez

    Congrats on new endeavors and new adventures

  • Adam Conway

    It was a pleasure getting to work with you on all the screenings and interviews and even writing for the site for like a day… I sure all your future endeavors will be great…

  • Carol

    Your site will be missed.  Good luck on you new ventures and keep us posted!

  • http://twitter.com/iggzy Ben Glasthal

    I’m gonna miss the site a lot. Been follwoing it for like 2-3 years and it was one of my top 2 movie news sites and as such I’ll feel the void instantly. I am, however, really happy you guys are choosing to end it and not being forced too and have your next move set up

  • http://twitter.com/iggzy Ben Glasthal

    I’m gonna miss the site a lot. Been follwoing it for like 2-3 years and it was one of my top 2 movie news sites and as such I’ll feel the void instantly. I am, however, really happy you guys are choosing to end it and not being forced too and have your next move set up

  • http://www.firstshowing.net Alex Billington

    Aw man, I am truly saddened to see you guys shut down GATW, but hopeful that you’ll be successful wherever life takes you. It was one of my favorite young websites that was run by my new favorite movie geeks/bloggers/lovers. All of you had a passion and love for movies and a spirit that everyone in the movie community seemed to enjoy, and I am honored to call many of you my friend. I wish all of you the best of luck and happiness on your next endeavors and adventures.

  • Larry Ratliff

    It’s the journey, lady and gentlemen.  What a great ride you guys had!  Here’s hoping the next chapter for each of you is even better.

  • Larry Ratliff

    It’s the journey, lady and gentlemen.  What a great ride you guys had!  Here’s hoping the next chapter for each of you is even better.

  • http://profiles.google.com/bianca.renee Bianca Sias

    I’d only recently discovered you guys in the past 6 months and regularly referred to your reviews before I decided to go to a movie. Thank you for your honesty, perspective, and insight. You will be missed. 

  • http://www.jonathanpsullivan.wordpress.com/ Jonathan Sullivan

    This really blows. GATW was my model of how to run a film blog once I got the balls to give it another real go as a site owner. I can’t wait to see where you all end up and all the sucess that’ll come your way.

    As a side note, it’s scary as an aspiring movie blogger to see a site this prominent have to shut its doors. Makes one nervous to continue pursuing the dream.

  • http://scifimafia.com Jason

    Wow! I’m shocked. Truth-be-told, GATW was one of the inspirations for starting my site back in 2009. Chase, you and your entire crew are, and have always been a class act.

    Yes, you’re all great writers with fantastic personalities, but your writing always showed a care and respect for your readers that other sites had been sorely lacking (something I’m proud to say I learned from you and intentionally applied to my own site from the get-go).

    If you don’t think your list of accomplishments and milestones is quite long enough, you can also add that, for awhile… you made the internet a better place. My best to all of you and good luck in everything you decide to take on, GATW will be sorely missed.

  • http://twitter.com/cinemabeach Bryan Thompson

    Sorry to see you go. I just recently started my own movie blogging website at cinemabeach.com and it worries me to see such talent leave the business. I would love any advice you guys may have as our group tackles the waters your team treaded so well. 

  • Recent Post