• MailChimp Widget

    GORDON AND THE WHALE NEWSLETTER



Sundance 2011 Review: RED STATE

Brian Kelley

by: Brian Kelley
January 27th, 2011

Rating: 2.5/5

Writer/Director: Kevin Smith
Cast: Melissa LeoJohn GoodmanMichael Angarano

Kevin Smith's hotly anticipated horror film, RED STATE, has finally debuted. The story of three teens who find themselves in the clutches of an extreme fundamentalist religious group is easily identifiable as a Kevin Smith film with extended scenes of quick banter. Beyond that, though, Smith has managed to introduce a certain amount of freshness in his filmography via some interesting direction and a level of suspense and action not present in his previous films. The end result, though, is a better-than-average horror film marred by lengthy, steam-stealing periods of dialog and thinly veiled social criticism. This is frustrating as there is a potentially very good movie hiding here.

RED STATE does not waste any time diving into exposition. The first scene takes place in a classroom where a teacher is explaining constitutional rights to her students. One young man arrives late having been slowed down due to a protest by the radical Five Points Church. Of course one student in the room has never heard of the church so the teacher explains they are a fundamentalist group led by Abin Cooper (the ever reliable Michael Parks) and proceeds to tie this in with the freedom of speech lesson. A group of three horny students from this class decide to go out to the township that houses the church, Cooper's Dell, to meet up with a prostitute advertising online. When they arrive, though, they quickly find out they have been lured into a trap and have become part of a lesson for the churchgoers including Abin's own daughter Sarah (Melissa Leo).

Up to this point in the movie there's been a good balance of the Kevin Smith we know and (sometimes) love, and the Kevin Smith that wants to make a serious horror movie. Early scenes have the three teen leads talking about the filthy things they will do when they get their hands on the woman in Cooper's Dell. Once they are on the dark road and figure out things are amiss, there's an air of creepiness that makes one hopeful for the rest of the film. However, it is after one of the best moments in the movie (an extremely effective scene shot from inside a covered cage) that the first wall is hit. Our introduction to the Reverend Cooper and his flock is via an extremely long, tedious sermon. There will be several more instances of this problem of the film coming to a grinding halt for extended scenes of dialog.

From here, things begin to escalate as the sermon turns deadly, our captive teens are desperate to survive and the ATF led by a sharp John Goodman is called in. The film drags with exposition once more with Goodman's introduction. Though it's well acted, the scene is mainly Goodman talking into a Bluetooth headset, explaining the church, its history, and why the ATF has an interested in them. The ATF, though, is quick to descend upon the compound. This is where the film is best, during the initial standout between the ATF and the  Five Points Church. Smith has never been known for his directing chops but there are several scenes in the mid-section of the film that are impressively staged. For a while, again, one has hope that things will ride the intensity to the finish. However, two concurrent and intertwined subplots (one inside the Four Points compound and one outside) develop that make it necessary for Smith to stop the action for more scenes of dialog that simply lack the snap needed to justify their length. It's this escalation, wall-hitting back-and-forth that makes the film ultimately frustrating.

There is a very good movie hiding inside RED STATE, even when annoyance sets in at the scattershot pacing, Smith seems to have a great surprise up his sleeve each time to get the movie rolling again. In fact, there are several standout moments, enough that it would be hard to write this off as a complete failure. Cohesiveness is not the film's strong point, though. As the situation builds in intensity and violence, the film plows towards a rather brilliant point where the film can go in two directions. Both directions have their pros and cons and it seems likely most will agree that the way RED STATE ends up has far more things going against it than for it.

The major problem with RED STATE is simple- Kevin Smith is incapable of dampening his ego long enough to pull off a straightforward horror film. He simply must make a statement, take his jabs at church and state alike. If things weren't so on the nose, though, if subtlety had been employed at any time during the scripting process, these critiques would be easier to swallow. The horrific and tense moments are there already, they should have been let loose in their own dark world, free of any surface level examination of the hypocrisy of extremism, devoid of moments of audience-demeaning exposition. Instead, Smith can't rely on the audience to see things such as the parallels between the Five Points Church and the real-life Westboro Baptist Church, he has to have someone actually spell them out in the film. Of course, maybe it is we the audience who should be blamed, going in we've already ignored the high school level multiple entendre of the title RED STATE.

Commenting Rules: Comments are intended to open up the discussion to our readers about the topics at hand, and as such should be offered with a positive and constructive attitude. If your comment is not relative to the above post or is disrespectful to the authors and readers, we reserve the right to delete it. Continued abuse of our good nature will result in banishment of the offender. Additionally, if you have any burning issues to point out to the GATW crew - typos, corrections, suggestions, or straight-up criticism - please email us instead of commenting here.

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention Sundance 2011 Review: RED STATE » GordonandtheWhale.com -- Topsy.com

  • Anonymous

    Hate films like this where it’s worth seeing and probably one you should avoid.

  • http://twitter.com/BTSjunkie Brian Kelley

    Thank you for commenting. I’m curious where I say it’s a “great movie” but I “cant [sic] stand it” because I “dont [sic] like Kevin”, I say that there is a “very good movie hiding inside RED STATE”. I make one comment indicating Smith’s ego, but talk about how that effects the film itself. All problems I had with the film are with what I saw on screen, not with Smith except for the fact that Smith wrote/directed it, the final product does reflect on him and his attitudes. Even if the filmmaker had been unknown to me I would have had the same problems.

    If you don’t see any jabs at church in the script, I don’t know what to say. I think a story about a Christian fundamentalist church becoming so radical that it begins threatening the lives of people they deem unfit for God is absolutely a jab at the power of unchecked religious fervor. I am familiar with Smith’s history as a Catholic. You don’t think DOGMA was humorously lambasting some of the more archaic principles in the Catholic church?

    I don’t hate the movie, I think I was very fair here. 2.5/5 is not a bad score, it’s not particularly good, but it’s certainly not a completely failure (as stated in the review).

  • http://twitter.com/BTSjunkie Brian Kelley

    Thank you for commenting. I’m curious where I say it’s a “great movie” but I “cant [sic] stand it” because I “dont [sic] like Kevin”, I say that there is a “very good movie hiding inside RED STATE”. I make one comment indicating Smith’s ego, but talk about how that effects the film itself. All problems I had with the film are with what I saw on screen, not with Smith except for the fact that Smith wrote/directed it, the final product does reflect on him and his attitudes. Even if the filmmaker had been unknown to me I would have had the same problems.

    If you don’t see any jabs at church in the script, I don’t know what to say. I think a story about a Christian fundamentalist church becoming so radical that it begins threatening the lives of people they deem unfit for God is absolutely a jab at the power of unchecked religious fervor. I am familiar with Smith’s history as a Catholic. You don’t think DOGMA was humorously lambasting some of the more archaic principles in the Catholic church?

    I don’t hate the movie, I think I was very fair here. 2.5/5 is not a bad score, it’s not particularly good, but it’s certainly not a completely failure (as stated in the review).

  • Pingback: Sundance 2011: RED STATE (2011) « BTS Junkie

  • http://topmovielinks.com/watch-movie-online/red-state.html Red State

    Well done, Mr. Smith.

  • http://profiles.google.com/krosok.adrenaline krosok adrenaline
  • http://profiles.google.com/krosok.adrenaline krosok adrenaline

    download Sundance 2011
    http://www.cinema1dua.co.cc

  • Recent Post